Joselyn Martinez is a singer. Let’s begin there.
She has written songs, recorded music, danced, acted and built a business. She also helped find the man who killed her father, doing the work that brought a long-closed case back before a New York court.
She’s done it all. And I want us to pay attention to all of it.
Joselyn is a friend of mine. I was in communication with her when she found her father’s killer and was going through all of this. It was tough. I can’t even imagine what she, her mother and her family had to endure at the time.
What she accomplished for her father was heroic, and I want her name remembered for it. I also want us to know the artist, the woman who went to college despite being discouraged, the entrepreneur who kept learning and began helping other women build something of their own.
This is about her. Her father belongs in the story. So do her mother, the family they built and the work they did. But Joselyn gets to have a life beyond the investigation that made her famous. She had dreams before the headlines. She has pursued others since.
She was singing before the headlines
In a video she shared on Instagram, Joselyn remembers a shy childhood on 136th Street, wanting to become a veterinarian, and the family friends who suggested she try castings. There were early headshots, dresses she loved, songs by Cyndi Lauper and Madonna. She had dreams long before the headlines.
She takes us into her parents’ lives, too. In her account, they came separately from the Dominican Republic to New York, met, worked jobs and eventually built a business. She describes their place in the history of Dominican fast food in Inwood. A restaurant was something they made together, a way to earn a living and build a future for their family. Her mother and father deserve recognition for what they built together.
There was music in that family. In a 2005 interview with Diario Libre, Joselyn recalled her father writing songs and arrangements and her mother loving to sing. She took voice lessons. She also described dancing internationally with Las Chicas del Can while pursuing her education, then deciding after college to concentrate on singing.
The interview introduced her planned debut, Movimiento subterráneo. She said she wrote most of its songs on the New York subway. Asked about its sound, she described pop, rock and merengue. She told Diario Libre that the decision to write and sing her own songs followed a frustrating search for producers who would follow through.
There is an artist here, a talented singer, songwriter and performer writing songs, finding a sound, knocking on doors and making decisions about her work. We should be curious about that work. What did she want to say? What did she learn by performing? What does she want to create now?
Her public biography describes recording a Latin pop album, appearing in commercials, contributing a voice to a Grand Theft Auto game and working as a stand-in for Jennifer Lopez.
And she got her education. In a 2021 Shoutout LA interview, she recalled a guidance counselor telling her not to consider NYU, including because of the cost. She went anyway and graduated. She had studied pre-law with her father’s case in mind, then decided she could pursue the performing arts, too.
How many times do our people have to hear some version of lower your expectations? The expense can be real. So can the lack of help. But a young person’s ambition deserves more than somebody pointing at the price and closing the conversation.
Joselyn kept going.
She helped bring her father’s case back
José Martinez was fatally shot outside the family’s restaurant on Dyckman Street on November 22, 1986. Joselyn was nine. She later described the restaurant to Crime Watch Daily as “our second home,” where the family gathered and held events.
That description matters. Before there was a case, there was a place this family worked and spent time together. Before her father became the man in a newspaper story about a killing, he had a wife, children, a business and songs of his own. The family photographs belong to that life. Give them our attention, too.
The New York court record establishes that police knew the killer’s identity. In a recorded 1987 call, he acknowledged the shooting while claiming self-defense. After his arrest in the Dominican Republic, New York closed its case in March 1988. José’s relatives had also acted, including his brother filing a criminal complaint there.
Joselyn sought information in 1996 and later searched online. In January 2013, police recovered the file and gave her the killer’s birth date, allowing her to identify the right Miami result. Detective Robert Dewhurst reopened the case, verified the identification and arrested the killer that June.
Contemporaneous Associated Press reporting published by The Spokesman-Review described her saving results in a laptop folder, paying for searches herself and writing to America’s Most Wanted. The newspaper’s June 12, 2013 headline made her achievement clear. Behind it were years of trying, gathering information and returning to the question.
I see genius in her detective work. She had to distinguish a useful result from another possible match, obtain information she was missing and bring it to someone with the authority to act. We are quick to recognize expertise when it arrives with a title. Joselyn learned what she needed to move this case forward. Her father mattered enough for her to try without knowing whether it would work.
The legal history needs to be told accurately. The New York indictment was dismissed in October 2014 because the state had not justified the long delay. That was a due-process ruling, not an acquittal after a murder trial. The killer had previously been convicted in the Dominican Republic in connection with José’s death and sentenced to one year. A separate federal naturalization case went through reversal and retrial, producing convictions and citizenship revocation. The Eleventh Circuit affirmed in 2020, and the Supreme Court denied review in 2021.
Joselyn could find him. She could not recover the years the state had let pass. In her account to the Observer, she described being at peace with knowing she had acted for her father. I respect that. The outcome does not erase her courage or the work she did.
She kept building a life of her own
What happens after the world learns your name for one extraordinary thing?
Joselyn kept creating. In that 2021 conversation, she described becoming interested in online business, managing social accounts and recognizing that she could build something without needing a storefront. Her parents had made a living through a restaurant. She was exploring the tools available to her.
Today, through The Modern Woman Mastermind, she describes helping women develop their offers, marketing and businesses, along with leadership work and workshops. Her emphasis is on creating a business that fits a life people want to live. She is using what she has learned to help someone else figure out a next step.
For Joselyn, satisfaction came from completing the search, even as continued attention from the media brought exhaustion. Her public biography describes the burnout she experienced while treating media appearances as compulsory, and her eventual realization that she was free to stop.
Good. She doesn’t owe the media the rest of her life.
Calling someone a hero should not become another job we assign her for the rest of her life. She did something courageous. She still gets to enjoy herself, change direction and decide which requests deserve her time. Our admiration ought to leave her room to live.
There is pleasure in her public accounts, too. Asked in the Shoutout LA interview how she would spend time with a visitor, she talked about gardens, views of New York, Dominican food with her mother and places she wanted to go. She also gave her mother credit for persevering after her father’s death. I want us to honor her mother’s perseverance, too.
A meal with her mother belongs in the portrait. So does the music. I want us to be interested when she is enjoying her life, when she is making something, when she has something to teach. We do not have to wait for another terrible thing to happen before paying attention again.
Let her have the whole story
Yes, I believe Joselyn’s life could make a powerful film. Look at what is already there: a family building a business in New York, a girl discovering performance, a woman writing songs on the subway, a search that changes a case. Then there is everything she does afterward.
Give the music time. Give her father a life before his death. Give her mother a perspective of her own. Let us understand what Joselyn was trying to build for herself while carrying this question about her family.
The suspense would be there. So would the work of learning how to sing, how to perform, how to search, how to begin again. A filmmaker would have plenty to investigate by taking her whole life seriously. And any project involving her cooperation should begin by asking what she wants to share and how she wants to participate.
My admiration does not depend on a production getting made. The achievement is already hers. The songs, the performances and the business are already part of her life. We can recognize them now.
Joselyn Martinez is a hero and an exemplary woman. She is an extraordinary Latina who deserves to be recognized for her art and her achievements as a singer, an actress and an entrepreneur. I want people to know her name and be curious enough to keep looking at what she does next.
She has given us plenty of reasons.
